Pre-coordinate Indexing Systems: PRECIS, POPSI and Chain Indexing

Pre-coordinate indexing systems refer to systems where index terms (or subject headings) are combined or "pre-coordinated" before they are assigned to a document. In these systems, multiple terms are linked together to represent a single concept or subject. These systems are used in libraries and information retrieval to facilitate access to documents based on their subject content.

Below, we explore three prominent pre-coordinate indexing systems: PRECIS, POPSI, and Chain Indexing.

---

1. PRECIS (Pre-coordinated Indexing System)

PRECIS is a pre-coordinate indexing system that was developed at the British Library in the 1960s. The system was designed to improve the precision and flexibility of indexing by allowing for the creation of complex subject descriptions.

Key Features of PRECIS:

Pre-coordination: The system allows for the combination of multiple index terms into a single phrase or concept before they are assigned to the document.

Syntax-based: PRECIS relies on a specific syntax to combine terms, often utilizing relationship terms (such as "of," "for," "in," or "on") to indicate the relationships between concepts.

Flexible: PRECIS allows for precise and nuanced representation of subjects by combining terms in ways that reflect the content's specific focus.

Controlled Vocabulary: Although the terms in PRECIS are selected from a controlled vocabulary, the syntax allows them to be arranged in various combinations to describe a document's subject matter.

Example of PRECIS:

Consider a book about the economic impact of climate change on agriculture in Sub-Saharan Africa. In PRECIS, the subject could be represented as:

"Climate change of economic aspects in agriculture of Sub-Saharan Africa"

This shows how several related terms (climate change, economic aspects, agriculture, and Sub-Saharan Africa) are pre-coordinated to create a precise subject description.

Advantages of PRECIS:

Richness of representation: It can represent complex ideas more effectively than simple keywords.

Improved specificity: Users can easily find documents with very specific topics due to the detailed indexing.

Disadvantages of PRECIS:

Complexity: The system's syntax can be difficult to master for indexers.

Limited scalability: It can be time-consuming to index large amounts of data with precision, making it less ideal for very large databases.

---

2. POPSI (Post-coordinate and Pre-coordinate Indexing)

POPSI is an indexing system that combines both pre-coordinate and post-coordinate indexing techniques. It allows for the flexibility of post-coordination while leveraging the pre-coordination advantages of combining terms before they are assigned to the document.

Key Features of POPSI:

Hybrid System: POPSI is a hybrid system that combines both pre-coordination and post-coordination. While it can use pre-coordinated subject headings, the system also allows indexers to link terms after assignment when necessary.

User-controlled Post-coordination: POPSI enables users to combine terms after the document has been indexed. This means that searchers can create their own combinations of terms to retrieve documents.

Pre-coordination for Precision: When precise subject representation is required, POPSI uses pre-coordination, where terms are combined into a single index phrase.

Example of POPSI:

For a book about the economic consequences of climate change on Sub-Saharan African agriculture, the pre-coordinated heading might be:

"Economic impact of climate change in agriculture of Sub-Saharan Africa"

However, a user can also search for terms post-coordinately like:

"climate change" AND "economic impact" AND "agriculture" AND "Sub-Saharan Africa"

Advantages of POPSI:

Flexibility: By combining pre-coordination with post-coordination, POPSI allows for greater flexibility and adaptability in indexing and searching.

Customization: Users can refine their searches after the fact by combining terms to better fit their needs.

Disadvantages of POPSI:

Complexity: The dual system can add complexity for both indexers and searchers, requiring more effort to understand both approaches.

Potential for ambiguity: Post-coordination might not always be as precise as pre-coordination in some contexts.

---

3. Chain Indexing

Chain Indexing is another form of pre-coordinate indexing, wherein concepts are connected together in a "chain" to represent a specific subject. It involves the linking of subject terms in a sequential or hierarchical order to form a compound subject heading.

Key Features of Chain Indexing:

Linear or Hierarchical Structure: Chain indexing uses a simple, linear structure where concepts are linked together, often in a series, to define a subject. It can also create hierarchical relationships between terms.

Hierarchical Organization: This method often represents relationships between terms by arranging them in an ordered sequence. For example, a term related to a geographical region might be linked to a broader subject.

Pre-coordination: Like PRECIS, chain indexing relies on pre-coordinating terms before assigning them to the document. The result is a compound heading that succinctly describes the content.

Example of Chain Indexing:

For a book on the economic effects of climate change on farming in Africa, chain indexing might produce:

"Climate change" → "Economic effects" → "Agriculture" → "Africa"

This chain shows how each term is connected to the next, providing a detailed and specific subject heading.

Advantages of Chain Indexing:

Clarity: It provides a clear representation of how concepts are related.

Efficiency: Chain indexing allows for precise subject representation using simple relationships between terms.

Disadvantages of Chain Indexing:

Limited flexibility: The structure of the chain might limit the ability to represent more complex or nuanced relationships between terms.

Potential for fragmentation: In some cases, the linear nature of chain indexing might break down complex subjects into overly simplified terms.

---

Conclusion

Each of these pre-coordinate indexing systems—PRECIS, POPSI, and Chain Indexing—has its unique features, strengths, and weaknesses. The choice of indexing system depends on the specific needs of the database or library system, the nature of the subject matter, and the amount of flexibility required for users. While PRECIS is useful for highly specific indexing, POPSI offers a balance of flexibility and pre-coordination, and Chain Indexing provides a simple yet effective method for linking concepts together.